More Mock Draft Mockery: First-Round Pick
The countdown to the NFL Draft has officially hit single digits. Who is going where?

Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached peak mock draft season. Do we really know who is going where? No, but the guessing games are as prevalent as ever.
Albert Einstein gets credited with the quote, “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.” Does this mean that certain draft experts who continue to predict the Packers take a wide receiver in the first-round meet the criteria of insanity? Maybe, because as history has shown us over and over again Green Bay will most likely not draft a wide receiver in the first-round. Safe bet.
Smart and safe draft choices could hold a team back from developing or could propel a team forward in success. That is the name of the draft game. Everything is a coin flip. How does one define making the correct selection? It may come across as much less exciting or predictable to fathom the Packers using their first pick on a defensive or offensive lineman or even a cornerback. Whether you agree with the philosophy or not, this formula has been GM Brian Gutekunst's bread and butter. I wonder, how often Gute and the Packers front office actually draft "the best player available" as oppose to catering the pick for position need.
How are the first-round mock draft picks unfolding?
It is interesting to observe how many mock drafts roughly three weeks ago had the Packers drafting Oregon defensive tackle Derrick Harmon at pick 23. Observing the latest and most recent mock drafts, Harmon does not even get a mention. The pre-draft chaos moves like a monsoon wave with its unpredictability. Out of twenty mock drafts from various media outlets and draft analysts, 60% had Green Bay drafting a player on defense while 40% had them drafting a player on offense.
One mock draft has the Packers trading with Tampa Bay moving up to pick 19 to draft Georgia DL defensive lineman Mykel Williams. Seems like a stretch of a prediction when most mock drafts have Williams still available at pick 23. The GM could make that move if he gets word Williams will get drafted before the Packers’ turn and Gute ambitiously believes “that is our guy”.
40% of mock drafts have the Packers selecting a defensive tackle or edger rusher. The defensive line is the Packers most glaring need for improvement, so it is not surprising that this is the majority consensus. Four different names were mentioned including Texas A&M DE Shemar Stewart who got 3 guesses while Georgia DL Williams also had 3 guesses. The other two names mentioned were Ole Miss DT Walter Nolen and Michigan DT Kenneth Grant.
25% of mock drafts have the Packers selecting a wide receiver. If we are referring back to recent history, this is alarming on the prediction scale of false hope. Maybe this will be the year they do draft an outstanding receiver in the first-round, but the odds are unlikely the top receivers will still be available at pick 23. Arizona WR Tetairo McMillan and Texas WR Matthew Golden were tied with the most guesses. The other receiver who received a mention was Missouri WR Luther Burden III. There could be more of a valuable pick available here for the Packers if none of these are on the board at selection time. Another player to keep an eye out for is Ohio State WR Emeka Egbuka.
20% of mock drafts have the Packers selecting a cornerback. If CB Jaire Alexander is still on the roster, why would the Packers draft a corner with their first pick? Would that be a sign of confirmation that the writing is on the wall of Alexander’s departure? It is still a complex situation that does not have precise clarity. East Carolina CB Shavon Revel Jr. got two guesses while Kentucky CB Maxwell Hairston and Michigan CB Will Johnson each received one. If Ole Miss CB Trey Amos falls to 23, that is the only corner I see the Packers selecting in the first-round. Otherwise, I do not see this happening with the Alexander situation still unresolved.
15% of mock drafts have the Packers selecting an offensive lineman. It is never a wrong decision to beef up the offensive line, but considering Green Bay picked OL Jordan Morgan last year in the first-round it is difficult to foresee Gutekunst doing this back-to-back years. However, do not be surprised if this is what happens. Three different names were mentioned including North Dakota St OL Gray Zabel, Texas OT Kevin Banks Jr, and Ohio St OT Josh Simmons.
I bet Green Bay selects a defensive lineman at pick 23. What position would you bet on the Packers drafting with their first-round pick?
PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.
__________________________
Mitchell Adams is a passionate lifelong Packer fan bringing a unique West Coast perspective, and also produces multiple podcast platforms, is a published author, and a proud Packers shareholder. Follow him on X at @mitchadams209.
__________________________




Comments (42)
Lime Caipirinha
April 15, 2025 at 03:34 pm
I believe everyone in GB secretly wants Jayden Higgins at 23. Has anyone written about how good he is? Built to fit the size/athleticism profile the team wants to draft and has skills to run all over the route tree. My feeling confirmed this after I watched a Steve Smith segment on his opinion agreeing with what my eyes saw. I mean, GB youtube channel just posted a prospect primer of T. McMillan. Meaning they aren't going to get him, and they don't think he is the best WR. This draft will likely not be an edge or Dline interior at 23 this year. Keep an eye on CB Jahdae Barron. That dude is the real deal. Teams are keeping their lips shut tight for good reasons. They are trying to disrupt a lot or be very, very quiet. Tells a lot of the story!
TKWorldWide
April 15, 2025 at 04:24 pm
Amon-Ra was a 4th. Just proves we really don’t know what’s out there.
Lime Caipirinha
April 15, 2025 at 05:42 pm
Yeah.. But its up to us to watch and come up with evaluations and understanding of the players our team(s) will be selecting. Ultimately its their job to determine in the moment but that doesn't discredit what we see in football players as fans. Let's not just dismiss my opinion of Jayden Higgins if I am sharing with the community information and an observation worth noting.
TKWorldWide
April 15, 2025 at 06:43 pm
Or we could just sit back and watch it all happen. 😀
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 06:22 pm
I don't know where the Packers had him ranked but he was clearly better than his brother in college. I was for them drafting him but at the time I thought there was still a chance ESB would turn out. Cutting him after drafting his brother would have been awkward.
Alberta_Packer
April 15, 2025 at 04:54 pm
I, not so secretly, prefer Tet McMillan @ 23. In fact, he is the only WR that I would select in the 1st round.
Lime Caipirinha
April 15, 2025 at 05:32 pm
You should be watching more film if that is how you feel. You wouldn't be a good GM lol. The team posting that video is just smoke and mirrors.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 07:36 pm
If he slides to 23 he'd be a value pick there. He might not be a burner but that doesn't matter much at WR and the receivers that kicked ass early in their college careers have much better odds of being successful in the NFL and he played his whole career like Golden played his last four games.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 07:11 pm
Not everyone! IMO Royals>Higgins both for what he Packers need this year and his upside.
stockholder
April 15, 2025 at 03:44 pm
If Gute trades back; the patriots fit.***
They need a OL and Wr.
The first 15 teams list DL as a NEED.
Based on those numbers-
Trading back for a DL fits. So =
38. Tyleik Williams. DT. OSU ***
54. Landon Jackson. Edge Ark
69. Tre Harris. WR. O MIs ***
87. Anthony Belton. OT. NC St.
123. Cam Jackson. DT. FL
159. Dillion Gabriel. QB. Oregon
200. Nick Nash. WR. San Jose st
238. Jason Marshall. Cb. Fl. ***
239. Brassard Smith. WR/RB. SMU
251. Esa Pole. Ol. Wash st.
Cam Jackson is climbing.
Due to lack of Run stuffing DTs
But this only works if you want a DT
Oxymoron 3339
April 15, 2025 at 04:02 pm
If Gute trades back in round 1?
You crack me up. This would be a good year to do that as we need a lot of help. Gute might not know how to trade down in round 1.
stockholder
April 15, 2025 at 04:47 pm
There was No #1 mentioned.
Follow the numbers. The *** for Trade.
jannesbjornson
April 15, 2025 at 08:38 pm
#28 Nic Scourton DE A&M
#54 Danny Stutsman LB OKIEs
#60 T. Henderson RB OSU
#93 Josh Farmer DT FSU
#159 Jalen Royals WR Utah State
#198 Jordan Watkins WR olde Mist
#237 D Alexander DT Toledo ( Will not leave rd 3)
#248 Jaylin Conyers TE T-Tech
#250 Elijah Badger WR Florida
Who will trade with him beside Wolf's kid, or Schneider? I would move UP for one of the top Wideouts. Get a threat for Love . A lot of these DTs are way over-rated.
LLCHESTY
April 16, 2025 at 12:32 am
Jalen Royals at 159?🤣
jannesbjornson
April 16, 2025 at 07:23 am
He was still there in Fantasy land. Some have him moving up to rd two. Usually, a Rd three guy.
stockholder
April 16, 2025 at 06:01 am
No CB ?
IMO -I still believe Gute's top pick somewhere, will be a CB.
You must like Ourlads.
jannesbjornson
April 16, 2025 at 07:22 am
Never read the site. This is BPA at the time of the Fantasy Simulation. Unless he packages Jaire in a Move Up for a guy; he probably stays onboard. His guy.
Celise...
April 16, 2025 at 09:57 pm
i don't see drafting a wide receiver in the first round until we find out if love can even hit his why receivers. he struggled with that last year. best shore up the defense first. to give him more opportunities.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 04:08 pm
Drafting another TJ Slaton in the 2nd round? Makes a lot of sense, except Williams has only played 34 A gaps snaps in the last 3 YEARS. Drafting a NT that has never played NT in the 2nd round? No Thank You.
stockholder
April 15, 2025 at 04:53 pm
Who says he's Slaton.?
If you want a DT -
He's a DT. And you get Harris.
Who might be the best fit at WR.
I took Work horses. Guys -
That will give you 3 downs.
Coldworld
April 15, 2025 at 05:17 pm
31. Walter Nolen DT Ole Miss
54. Jack Bech WR TCU
87. Ashton Gillotte EDGE Louisville
95. Deone Walker DT Kentucky
124. Isaac TeSlaa WR Arkansas
159. Mello Dotson. CB Kansas
198. Jackson Hawes. TE Georgia Tech
237. Torricelli Simpkins III. OC South Carolina
250. Gerad Christian-Lichtenhan OT Oregon State
stockholder
April 15, 2025 at 05:47 pm
Nolen projects into a DE by some.
But the trick is to get the #69 pick.
Thats where they could get any WR to fit.
And still take 2 Def. players earlier.
The #95 is the drop off.
And with the demand on DTs .
Deone won't last that long.
But you still got something right.
Taking two DTs!
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 05:55 pm
Deone Walker has slid 50 spots on the consensus board since the combine. But you're probably right, and any GM can put this film on and realize as a pass rusher he's going to run circles around Tyleik Williams. The question is does he trust the D line coach to coach him out of the bad habit of playing too high? I'd say it's about 50/50 Walker slides into the 4th, depends on if there's a run or if teams are content to wait on the big guys knowing there's a lot more in the draft than normal.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 07:13 pm
Link where someone said Nolen projects to DE! 🤣He's to short to be a prototypical 3-4 DE and he's not playing outside in a 3-4. Where do you come up with this stuff?
stockholder
April 16, 2025 at 05:52 am
The Huddle report player profiles.- Cut and paste parts
Walter is a Defensive Edge Rusher in a Defensive Tackles body. I think moving him to a defensive end position would benefit him dramatically. Walter has the size, length, body type, and excellent overall athletic talent, of a pure defensive end. He has the explosion off the line of scrimmage like an Edge Rusher too. He does not like to take on blocks and make tackles at the line of scrimmage.
Coldworld
April 16, 2025 at 08:30 am
His athleticism might suggest the potential to be a very big DE, but I think that’s stretching it and his short arms probably kill it as a serious regular proposition although, like the similarly described Brooks, he could be moved around situationally.
The Packers, however, have not used Brooks on the edge really. I think Nolan can be a more productive DT than Brooks and better versus the run, but I accept that I think Brooks could be more productive than he has been with better coaching/usage.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 06:32 pm
The only difference I see between Dotson and Nohl Williams is that Williams is a ball hawk. I like Jalin Conyers over Hawes because I like his TE2 upside and athleticism more but either one is better than they have now. I try to go OL earlier but have ended up with drafts like this, not a lot of Packer types in this draft and it's unknown how far Gutey is loose in the thresholds. Some of the OL players they've brought in on visits have horrible abilities numbers but that nothing new for his UDFA. Have to say I liked TT's approach to UDFA linemen better, grab athletes and hope you can coach them up.
Coldworld
April 16, 2025 at 08:42 am
Williams is a ball hawk without speed or agility. He’s another Kemal Hadden who went in the 6th last year and is on our 90. I don’t see a major upgrade or reason to duplicate that player type. Every once in a while that’s a depth piece in center field but seldom more. Often those that survive end up at S.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 07:18 pm
I did one where I picked guys I don't really want to see them pick but wouldn't be surprised if they did and they didn't take a DT til late and how would I try to rectify the situation.
Jay Toia is a NT that would compete with Hutmacher to replace Slaton and Brinson is kind of a tweener that did the dirty work at Georgia but could thrive in a more penetrating system. His upside would be a B gap player on early downs and an A gap player on passing downs. Poor man's Clark. It's interesting that Brinson is good at some of the tests Kenny wasn't and vice versa but both tested well on the bench.
30.
Shavon Revel
CB East Carolina
54.
Jayden Higgins
WR Iowa State
66.
J.T. Tuimoloau
EDGE Ohio State
109.
Tory Horton
WR Colorado State
173.
Jonah Monheim
OC USC
177.
Dalton Cooper
OT Oklahoma State
198.
Caleb Ransaw
CB Tulane
202.
Jalin Conyers
TE Texas Tech
237.
Jay Toia
DT UCLA
250.
Warren Brinson
DT Georgia
257.
Nash Hutmacher
DT Nebraska
2026 BUF 4th
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 05:49 pm
3 downs? Let me see if I can break this "down" for you. Williams played only 34 A gap snaps so he was rarely double teamed. Slaton played over 300 A gap snaps in college. Williams had 52 pressures in 799 passing snaps, Slaton had 43 in 475 passing snaps. Williams had the more advantageous position and did worse on a per snap basis. He doesn't use his hands well, lets OL get into his chest and has trouble disengaging, the same exact thing I've watched Slaton do the last four years, although he has gotten a little better.
He's TJ Slaton if TJ Slaton hadn't played NT in college, but a worse pass rusher. Like Georgia not every player on a championship D turns out to be a good pro. I'd bet money on Williams being nothing more than a two down run stuffer and you don't waste 2nd round picks on two down run stuffers.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 07:38 pm
Yeah but I want a GOOD DT. Big difference.
stockholder
April 16, 2025 at 10:39 am
Then read Walters Football-
His only negative, is his weight gain.
Walters has him rd 1 #23 on their board.
Trust them. Walter's has been spot on.
jannesbjornson
April 16, 2025 at 07:39 pm
...
GregC
April 15, 2025 at 06:29 pm
In order of likelihood, I think it's DT, DE, WR, CB, OL. I'm hoping for WR or DT. I think CB makes no sense in the first round even if they are moving on from Alexander, which they probably are. If they go OL, I will be angry. The DEs all make me nervous. Lots of bust potential in all of those that may be available.
MooPack
April 15, 2025 at 06:59 pm
I think it will boil down to two players. OT - Josh Simmons and DT - Derrick Harmon. If both are there, pick one. If one is there, pick him. If both are gone, trade down, if they can. I don't see a WR worthy of a 1st round pick and neither a CB. WR is a weak top end class. CB class where the packers will pick has too many short comings in one area or another. Get the trenches right first. Build out from there. Time tested approach.
LLCHESTY
April 15, 2025 at 07:15 pm
If they pick Harmon I hope it's because Nolen and Grant are gone, he has more questions and isn't close to the run defender the other two are.
MooPack
April 15, 2025 at 07:45 pm
I wrote this is another thread:
"Harmon had 45 tackles, same amount as top DT Mason Graham, 11 tackles for loss, 5 sacks, and 55 pressures last year (**12 more than any other IDL in FBS**), 4 Pass Def, and 2 FF. His stats are better than the two Michigan DT's."
Nolen - 48 tackles, 6.5 sacks, 14 TFLs, 35 pressures, 3 Pass Def.
Similar, but I give edge to Harmon. Also, Harmon 34 3/8 Arms to Nolen 32 1/2. That's two inches. 10 3/8 to 9 1/2 Hands for Harmon. That's a total of 3 inches more length (or 2.75 technically depending on span). Harmon ~15 lbs more weight. That puts me over the top for Harmon.
LLCHESTY
April 16, 2025 at 12:30 am
Nolen 13% run stop rate, 4.5% missed tackle rate. Harmon 7..5% run stop rate, 27%Mosed Tackle Rate. That's not an error, 27% MTR. Plus Nolen is smaller but shows way more power in his game.
PackyCheese500
April 16, 2025 at 10:39 pm
Harmon is the better pass rusher, and that's what the Packers need. Grant is already a great run defender and has immense pass rushing upside (especially since it was he, not Mason Graham, getting double-teamed at Michigan). Nolen is like Wyatt - has too many almost-sacks. Harmon or Grant would be my preference over Nolen
gsd3
April 16, 2025 at 04:28 am
I have my crushes and my players I don't want at all. Really don't care what order a position is drafted. Just hoping for upgrades in the 1st 3 rounds at any given position and solid depth thereafter.
PackyCheese500
April 16, 2025 at 10:33 pm
If we end day 1 of the draft with one of Derrick Harmon, Kenneth Grant, or Emeka Egbuka, I'd be thrilled! Harmon was a beast at Oregon and led the nation in DT pressures and was top-10 among all d-linemen. Grant was often the one commanding double teams at Michigan, not Mason Graham, and could fill Slaton's role while he develops as a pass rusher. Egbuka is just what the Packers WR room needs. A guy who can create separation and doesn't drop passes. He has the size to play outside, is a great blocker, and comes from a school (Ohio St.) where basically every WR is an NFL star.
I really hope the Packers do not draft Shemar Stewart or, even more so, Mykel Williams. Both are busts waiting to happen.
Handsback
April 17, 2025 at 09:42 am
I have no idea who Green Bay will pick. 22 teams will make their selection before the Pack hands in their selection. They could trade up, but don't see that one player who's a major difference maker over existing roster players. Better yes but not a difference maker.
How much do you pay for a better position player by moving up in the draft?
That is why I think they wait and see who falls, or trade down.
Just MHO