Confessions of a Polluted Mindset - Who's in Command?
The Weekly Packers Brain Drain from Jersey Al.
By JerseyAl
- While I went for the easy pun, "who's in command" is really the main question I have about these Green By Packers - and specifically the offense. It's hard for me to understand the scheme they are running based on the personnel they have. Good coaches find the style that best suits the abilities of the players. Of course, LaFleur's hands are a bit tied, although it's his own fault for being so deferential to Aaron Rodgers right from the get-go. It's likely too late at this point to try to wrest full control of his team, so the success of this team is likely in serious jeopardy.
- In my prediction for this game, I stated that a loss to Washington would be on a par with the loss to Arizona that got McCarthy fired. Of course, no one is getting fired here, but that doesn't mean you couldn't build a case for it.
- Not Stoked for Doubs - It was a really rough day for Eric Stokes and Romeo Doubs. I have a feeling they're the two main guys Rodgers was referring to when he said players that are making too many mistakes shouldn't be playing so much. Although I do wonder if that applies to himself, also?
- More than the losses to the Giants and Jets, this game truly was a comedy of errors and "almosts." The defense could have easily had 4-5 interceptions in the first half, all of which would have given the ball to the Packers in Washington territory.
- Jaire and Douglas were hot and heavy with the smack talk early in this game. They were balling and overall, played well all game. Jaire, however, got himself humbled a few times and we was much quieter after that.
- Ron Rivera with some words the Packers should pay attention to. "We ran the ball effectively," Rivera said. "When you can do that, you can chew the clock and you can possess the ball. It seems to be a pretty good formula." Um, we wouldn't know...
- DBak - Gotta feel for the guy. My total guess is that he's still needing to get the knee drained regularly. Hard to criticize him, but plenty of asshole Packers fans still do.
- Give Joe Barry some credit - he's reading CheeseheadTV and trying some of the things we keep asking for here.
- Sure seems that AJ Dillon is being marginalized more every game. I get that he hasn't lit the world on fire, but you would think on fourth and one they would make use of him. But no, let's throw a WR bubble screen.
- Funniest thing from this game? Rodgers yelling "WTF are we doing?" to the bench after throwing a pass to the ankles of a stationary and wide open Romeo Doubs.
__________________________
"Jersey Al" Bracco is the Editor-In-Chief, part owner and wearer of many hats for CheeseheadTV.com and PackersTalk.com. He is also a recovering Mason Crosby truther. Follow Al on twitter at @JerseyalGBP.
Comments (127)
Savage57
October 26, 2022 at 06:25 am
We're seeing something these last few weeks and it sure ain't pretty. The brain drain the Packers went through in the offseason maybe just as impactful, if not more so, than the player talent loss. This 2022 team looks lost. Inept on offense, soulless on defense, and there's no one any good at map reading on the coaching staff anymore. Matt LaFleur is kind of being exposed as a cruise-control head coach because week in and week out it's the "let's do more of what's not working, but harder!" strategy with the expected results.
Hackett, Getsy, and Stenavich were integral parts of an offense that was light years ahead of the current iteration production-wise. Two are gone, and one has been Peter Principled to the OC position.
BuckyBadger
October 26, 2022 at 09:57 am
Hackett wasn't bringing much to the table and his job in Denver is showing that. This is a result of bad drafting and not replacing talent as it aged.
Roadrunner23
October 26, 2022 at 06:41 am
WTF are we doing? Sums up the season so far!
Now there is a lot of season left to play out but……
My questions are as follows:
Why do you sign this QB to a $50 million deal and not bring in any legit guys to throw too except the broken down Sammy Watkins and some draft choices?
Why isn’t Degura “the great Swiss Army knife” being used more? Tonyan isn’t exactly George Kittle!
If the RB’s are your best Offensive chess pieces, Why the F’’K aren’t they using them ALOT?
The Packers finally paid up to fix the Special Teams debacle (after being cheap asses) and brought in some good Teams guys. Them why the F’’k didn’t they finish the job and get a real return man?
Why when Aaron Rodgers called for the benching of players who aren’t holding up their end, did no one ask where he was all offseason to build chemistry with these guys?
Why doesn’t somebody take away MLF’s man card? His Vagina is showing!
That is all…
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 08:03 am
You bring up some good questions.
"Why isn’t Degura “the great Swiss Army knife” being used more? Tonyan isn’t exactly George Kittle!"
Deguara looked really good in back to back games. He needs to be used more. I think he is a guy that could really help the offense out.
They need to find guys that can gain them 5-10 yards routinely. Deguara could be that guy.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 11:52 am
Why isn’t LaFleur’s system, so effective in 2020, being used? It’s not just Deguara.
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 04:06 pm
Not just Deguara. But I do think he is a piece they can use to help solve the puzzle. With the WR's struggling a bit. Using the TE's more could be a part of the solution.
jannesbjornson
October 26, 2022 at 07:22 pm
All three TEs need to put pressure on the opponent's defense, not just block the corner and decoy with the ducks.
The offense has staccato rhythm, nothing is in fast flow. Some need to sit, it is obvious.
LLCHESTY
October 26, 2022 at 04:55 pm
They need to find a guy that can catch a 20 to 40 yarder routinely, then the 5 to 10 yarders will get much easier. Can't hurt the running game either.
jannesbjornson
October 26, 2022 at 07:26 pm
They should be dealing as we speak. If they sit on their hands, at least get Toure' rolling and ditch Amari. Watson can run the six route tree of MVS.
LLCHESTY
October 27, 2022 at 02:34 am
Fuller is oft injured but if healthy the one thing he does very well is catch the deep ball. His catch rate is really good for YPC. At the very least bring him in.
barutanseijin
October 26, 2022 at 09:04 pm
Do they have a quarterback that can consistently get the ball to guys 20-40 downfield?
LLCHESTY
October 27, 2022 at 02:35 am
Yes
croatpackfan
October 26, 2022 at 08:08 am
RR23, all the right questions.
1) $50 mill - because with that contract they were NOT able to pay legit WR1. And, possibly they were starting rebuilding vs all in idea. Because they did it twice and that one which was supposed to bring another trophy choked on both occasions. Pick what looks more suitable for you.
2) Because $50 mill guy do not trust him enough.
3) Because $50 mill guy can not adapt himself not being the focal point of the team and desperatly try to be.
4) See under point one. I have no other explanation.
5) Because he is perfect and never doing anything wrong or because he was preoccupied with tea party in South America. He was better when he was drinking wisky.
I posted a week or so that $50 mill guy talks about accountability, but never ever apply that to himself. And I was called out that ACR never talked about accountability (sic!).
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 08:58 am
So AR is the only problem with the team? If they bench him, they win games? Is that how I am supposed to read this?
croatpackfan
October 26, 2022 at 09:48 am
No, read what is written. There is no text or meaning behind. Thank you.
Packerpasty
October 26, 2022 at 01:57 pm
bulls**t, your like a broken record week after week...its all on Rodgers, at least to you...your hate is apparent...almost laughable...
croatpackfan
October 26, 2022 at 03:28 pm
NO, it is not on ACR. He is not guilty who he is. The guilt is on team management, the biggest on Mark Murphy who put himself, by himself in the shoes in which he do not know how to walk.
I said that many times, but you read what you want. Did I ever said that ACR is guilty for that contract? NO. I never said that. I said the guilt is on Mark Murphy first and foremost.
Second, Packers are not using more than one player on the roster because ACR do not believe they might be good. He is not familiar with them. At least he, by himself said that.
Third, he wants to be in the center of attention. If you do not recogfnize that, i can't help you.That is observation to explain why he is not "team player". Nothing more or less.
Fourth. Look under 1st paragraf were I explain why Packers did not sign so called WR 1. You will not get him under the price of Watkins. That is sure. And excellent PR & KR are expensive.
Fifth. He is aleays blaming others for everything, It is always others mistake. Never his. From football, to lying, through vaccination status or using halucinogen drugs insead to prepare himself for the season...
Sixth. Did he ever say to fans something like this: "Sorry fans I completely screw last possession by not seen open guys. This is only on me. I'm the guilty one!" Or, after 2020 loss to Bucs, something like: "Oh, my God, I didn't see Allan Lazard who was alone 1 yard away of the end zone and, knowing he is wonderful blocker, I might run by myself to the end zone. I screw it!" No he was furious for MLF call of FG, what was, by my opinion (and I might be wrong) correct decision, because second half of that game was playing bad offense. By 3 points you cut deficit to just 5 points and you'll need just TD, not even conversion to win. And you had enough time for your D to stop opponent and have one full 2 minutes possession. But, that is another story.
So, for $50 mill I'm not blaming ACR. I'm blaming him for selfishness, throwing young guys under the bus expecting them to elevate their game publicly calling to bench them. It is not you should expect from you fellow team mate. But, I forget that you are in the club "ACR is never guilty. Always others are!"
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 11:58 am
AR is a problem, but only one of many and certainly not the root in terms of his play. In my view it’s impossible to know how significant or not he is in the mix because it’s all dependent on who is doing what or has the power. We can’t know and that’s distracting a lot of people into a therefore blind alley.
LaFleur is the problem on the field and yet really it’s Murphy. LaFleur sets the attitudinal tone and expectations for the team. If he doesn’t, he’s no business being there and he is a problem of major proportions for that reason because that would entail chaos and contradictions running riot.
Murphy is responsible for a FO heading in one direction yet cap going in another. It’s dysfunctional on and off the field at all levels. That manifests in the roster we went into this year with, in the cap straight jacket we created to do so, in the confusion and mindset a portent in coaching and in the pathetic training camp mindset as well as the terrible O design we have trotted out that is self defeating, destroying confidence and an open book to defenders. By it’s very nature that puts Rodgers in a bad position on the field.
Tekraut17
October 26, 2022 at 09:49 am
They had enough $'s after AR's $50m to still pursue Davante so you can't blame AR for them not having enough $'s to pursue another WR. I'd say they couldn't find anyone left that hadn't already signed or anyone that they thought was that much better than what they had...
Now if your argument was that AR wasn't playing up to the $50m level I'd agree as a lot of his throws are not typical AR accurate BUT is that because of protection, inexperienced WR's, thumb, etc..most likely a combo of all the above.
Just run the damn ball and I think the passing game wouldn't have so much pressure on it.
PeteK
October 26, 2022 at 11:02 am
In order to run the damn ball you need an O line that will BLOCK. On at least two plays Jones was blown up in the backfield as soon as he got the ball, killing drives.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 12:04 pm
Thank the stars that didn’t happen. That would have killed us for a decade in guaranteed dead money to do what? Get us back to last year when we blew it but without MVS? To do that we also would probably have not been able to resign others. We’d be weaker now in other areas and in the future too.
EnemyTerritory
October 26, 2022 at 06:20 pm
Do not forget that the 50m man also took time to think about his plans thus freezing the front office from doing anything receiver wise. One can argue that the 50m man’s indecision (aka subdued Favre) also cost them or contributed to Adams failure to return. By the time that was resolved there wasn’t much WR1 talent to chase
SinceLombardi
October 26, 2022 at 12:03 pm
The answer to a lot of your … why didn’t they?” 12 killed the cap. And they probably overpaid for D Campbell. A shrewd GM might have found a decent linebacker for less.
stockholder
October 26, 2022 at 06:55 am
The spot light is on Rodgers and not this team. Let's feel Sorry for everyone but Rodgers. If it's too soon to get LeFluer out of here.
Let's go for Rodgers Jugular. WE get it. The MVP awards don't mean crap. Because he's just not playing up to his ballon salary.
He's the reason for No more trophies, and we've had enough of his baloney.
We'll welcome to the Dan Morino Dolphins. Obviously Lefluer is Dan Devine. And I'll bet.the fans will soon compare Gutey to Sherman.
No- You don't bench Rodgers and Blow everything up. Because Gutey wanted to put Love in Rodgers shoes.
Hero ball doesn't exist on good teams. And good teams wouldn't have this OL. Rodgers should be shooting fish in a barrel.
Instead he's doing what LeFluer's coaching staff didn't do. Bringing the problems to a head. Even if it means his head on a silver platter.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 12:11 pm
He is certainly bringing the issues to a head. I don’t think quite as much for the general good as you seem to see it. For one thing, who is his audience? Public opinion? Of whom?
These things are said in private to team meetings if designed to bring benefit. Public comments are aimed at achieving what that is positive?
stockholder
October 26, 2022 at 03:45 pm
Think about this CW. Adams got bitched at by the WR coach in front of a TV audience. Remember that.
Rodgers is doing the bitching because this WRs coach, has no balls to do that.
Tundraboy
October 26, 2022 at 07:07 am
Great work Al. At least we here are all on the same page. Wish the team was. Clueless coaching and now the QB.
NickPerry
October 26, 2022 at 07:09 am
"I have a feeling they're the two main guys Rodgers was referring to when he said players that are making too many mistakes shouldn't be playing so much. Although I do wonder if that applies to himself, also?"
AND
"Rodgers yelling "WTF are we doing?" to the bench after throwing a pass to the ankles of a stationary and wide open Romeo Doubs."
I hate to sound like a broken record but this is EXACTLY the kind of shit I was talking about yesterday in my comments. Rodgers once again blames everybody else. Rodgers should know every time he points a finger at someone else he's got 3 pointing back at himself. Corny? Sure, but it's also true. ESPECIALLY when Rodgers is criticizing others instead of looking at what HE could do better... IMO theres A LOT of things he could be doing better.
T7Steve
October 26, 2022 at 07:29 am
Don't you think it's the royal "WE"? Has he ever said anything that wasn't about himself?
Stokes and Douds are so young that they have to make mistakes to get better. The coaches should penalize Stokes for the sideline unsportsmanlike but, the action ones are going to happen. Who could they replace his speed with? Get Kevin King to sign up?
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 08:07 am
Honestly I would have liked to have seen one of the coaches grab Stokes by the facemask drag him to the bench, told him to get his shit together and that shit is not tolerable. Make him sit out for a few plays then put him back in.
Some times these guys need a wake up call.
That being said, there was some ticky tacky crap being called. That push he gave will draw the flag every time. But how is it any different then when guys start pushing each other on the field.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 03:08 pm
Attitude needs to be harnessed, but at least it was present in Stokes and the CBs generally. Hopefully he learns and a short spell on the bench may have helped, but it’s hardly the reason for what happened overall.
Tundraboy
October 26, 2022 at 10:07 pm
Yeah, I'm sure his teammates want to go through a wall for him. I'm now convinced that a lot of mistakes are out of fear that God forbid they make a mistake and piss him off and get his stare down. He is the definition of being full of himself. All the talent in the world works when you are at your peak but when you are just as prone to errors as everyone else there has to be some head shaking around the roster. Own up ARod and put this team on your shoulders or just shut up.
egbertsouse
October 26, 2022 at 07:39 am
Who’s in command? Come on, we all know who’s really in command in GB.
I hope LaFlower was watching Pat McTankTop’s show so he can get his marching orders for the next game.
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 07:51 am
- "While I went for the easy pun, "who's in command" is really the main question I have about these Green By Packers - and specifically the offense. It's hard for me to understand the scheme they are running based on the personnel they have. Good coaches find the style that best suits the abilities of the players. Of course, LaFleur's hands are a bit tied, although it's his own fault for being so deferential to Aaron Rodgers right from the get-go. It's likely too late at this point to try to wrest full control of his team, so the success of this team is likely in serious jeopardy."
I mean I just think the players need to make the plays that are called. Regardless of who is calling them. If they would stop dropping catchable passes, stop lining up wrong and just having negative plays, maybe they could actually do something on offense.
- In my prediction for this game, I stated that a loss to Washington would be on a par with the loss to Arizona that got McCarthy fired. Of course, no one is getting fired here, but that doesn't mean you couldn't build a case for it.
- "Not Stoked for Doubs - It was a really rough day for Eric Stokes and Romeo Doubs. I have a feeling they're the two main guys Rodgers was referring to when he said players that are making too many mistakes shouldn't be playing so much. Although I do wonder if that applies to himself, also?"
I am wondering who he is talking about. Clearly there are a few players that he thinks shouldn't be getting as much playing time as others. Could AJ Dillon be one? He has not been catching a lot of passes of late. He had another bad drop in this game. One that would have gained a lot of yards.
As far as Rodgers himself, he hasn't been perfect. But anyone that wants to blame Rodgers for the Washington game, needs to rewatch it. 7/8 dropped passes. A ton of penalties. A defense that dropped 4 interceptions. Their punt returner that changed the momentum of the game.
- "More than the losses to the Giants and Jets, this game truly was a comedy of errors and "almosts." The defense could have easily had 4-5 interceptions in the first half, all of which would have given the ball to the Packers in Washington territory."
The defense while played really well in the first half, struggles with making game changing plays that could put teams away. Then they can't get the stops when they need to. Its time we stop saying 'well he is a db for a reason'. No enough of that excuse. catch the damn ball. Make a play!
- "Ron Rivera with some words the Packers should pay attention to. "We ran the ball effectively," Rivera said. "When you can do that, you can chew the clock and you can possess the ball. It seems to be a pretty good formula." Um, we wouldn't know..."
I will say that Jones can bust one at any point. But they have not ran the ball well at all. Perhaps with the new OL and after a week of playing together they will start to gel. They do need to get more attempts. But they have to stop holding, and stop getting into negative situations.
- "DBak - Gotta feel for the guy. My total guess is that he's still needing to get the knee drained regularly. Hard to criticize him, but plenty of asshole Packers fans still do."
This will probably be the way it will be the rest of the year. I will say though I liked the way Tom played. He has a lot to learn, but I thought he played well.
- "Give Joe Barry some credit - he's reading CheeseheadTV and trying some of the things we keep asking for here."
As in blitzing Quay off the edge? Yup. about time he listened.
- "Sure seems that AJ Dillon is being marginalized more every game. I get that he hasn't lit the world on fire, but you would think on fourth and one they would make use of him. But no, let's throw a WR bubble screen."
Dillon has marginalized himself. He has not played well this year so far. He is looking slow. He is not breaking tackles or making anyone miss. He has been dropping passes. I like Dillon but he has not been very good. His rookie year he averaged 5.3 yards per carry. Last year he averaged 4.3. Currently he has averaged 3.9. For receptions last year he averaged 9.2 yards per catch. THis year 6.2. He simply hasn't been as dynamic. I am a big fan of Dillon. He just hasn't been that good. Perhaps some of it is from the OL. Maybe this new OL will allow the RB's to have greater success.
However I think its time to start using another RB some. Clearly they have no trust in Taylor. He has yet to have a carry or anything on offense. Either get Hill on the roster or bring up Goodson. Goodson I think would be a great option for the offense in terms of the passing game. They could use him in the Ervin type of role. Motion, and in the passing game. He could be a very good piece to add.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 12:17 pm
When it takes ten miles to go one, the likelihood is that the path is designed to avoid an obvious problem.
You are running miles to avoid the real issues. To not let go of the hope of salvation. Sometimes I do that. I read my own arguments and they tell me more clearly than any other source that I’m trying to square a circle. Then I know that I have to cut through to the real issue and stop trying to shore up fantasies by burying them under trivia and tangents.
Sorry, but I see your many posts as attempting just that. It’s better to get to the lifeboats than argue the boat is unsinkable until after it has.
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 02:37 pm
I'm not running anywhere to be honest. I'm just pointing out the honest truth as I see it.
Its easy to blame someone and throw shade everywhere. I just choose to not do it. There is a lot of blame to go around. This isn't just a 1 person thing.
If you want to know why they haven't played well, look at 2 positions. OL and WR. That is the reason the offense has struggles. The OL has had a number of different rotations and players simply aren't playing up to their abiliities.
WR has been a trainwreck. And that is because of injuries. Today at practice Lazard is out, Watkins and Watson we can assume are limited. That leaves us with Doubs (who I really like), Rodgers, Toure. And then the PS guys. Its a mess. Plain and simple. So naturally there is no threat on the outside. Teams don't have to worry about playing deep and can focus on stopping the run game or throws to the RB's.
That being said, the WR's have dropped a ton of catchable passes this year. And they have come at worst times. Doubs dropped the game winning TD. Luckily they won it in OT. He has multiple 3rd and 4th down drops. Lazard has been having those. We just need those guys to play better.
No one has to agree with me. I just try to call it the way I see it. Whether I'm right or wrong, it doesn't matter. Most of us are hear because we Love out team and want to see the best out of them. I am one of them.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 03:18 pm
There’s a commenter that is one of the ones I typically read with great interest, to whom I pointed out yesterday that he’s describing a team with terrible leadership consistently and right about identifying symptoms but always backs off from the logical conclusion he’s laid in front of us.
Here I was referring to Rodgers. He isn’t THE problem, his play is A problem. There no point in trying to mitigate that by shifting blame onto the players around him. They share the blame but a lot if it is Rodgers not being accurate or on time, as much as not catching heavily contested passes in traffic.
You pointed to the next step in the chain of causation and responsibility when stating that you don’t understand this O. No, because it’s incredibly self defeating for the team, for Rodgers and the WRs.
Why is that? Who is to blame for that? I’ve give. My views, but that’s the route to the answers. Rodgers himself seems still to be missing the woods for the trees (leaving out the target and motive debate). Passes are awry and receivers in traffic and covered because of the O that is run. The rest is symptoms not the cause and thus not a route to a cure.
RCPackerFan
October 26, 2022 at 04:02 pm
Rodgers is a part of the problem for sure. Some of his throws have been inaccurate. Some of which we don't 100% know if its based on the route ran or whatever. Some though are just fundamentals. There are a number of throws to the RBs out of the backfield that they are leaping for the ball and have to adjust to it. If he throws a more accurate pass perhaps the RB's gain a lot more yards. He needs to own that. Now right now I have no clue if its the thumb or something different.
As for the passing game and who he is supposed to throw to and all of that. Unless we know everything about the play we really can't say who is right or wrong on it.
I think the biggest problem has been the OL. They just have been struggling. Lets be honest with ourselves. Jenkins is not playing close to his pro bowl level. That has hurt. Myers is still learning as is Runyan. Bakhtiari has been in and out. The OL has been a mess. They haven't opened up holes for the RB's or given Rodgers time to find people. I do like the lineup they went with in this last game. I hope moving forward that is our OL.
The WR's just have to stop dropping 3rd down passes. They have to find ways to sustain drives. They have struggled with that big time. That has been haunting this offense. I don't care about play calls and whatnot. They just have to make the plays when given the chance.
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 07:53 am
I think Al could have started a couple of levels higher when he was talking about "Who's in command"?
Gute has clearly been drafting for the post Rodgers era with an emphasis on defense, offensive linemen, running backs and a first round replacement QB. Murphy hires a coach to be best buddies with Rodgers and then resigns Rodgers to a cap breaking deal. Do these guys even talk? You have the organization president and the director of the draft pulling in completely opposite directions which has resulted in a mismatched roster and coaching staff.
Either Gute should have been drafting WRs for a Rodgers led offense (starting with the Jordan Love pick) or Rodgers should have been traded to Denver this off-season. Neither happened and the resulting mess should surprise no one. "Who's in command" starts at the top, not just at the HC level.
Razer
October 26, 2022 at 08:09 am
Good points Guam. There has been a disconnect between the front office and the team going back to Favre. The reluctance to spend much top draft capital on offensive weapons, read WR, RB and TE, has been chronic. The Packers have handicapped two of the best QBs of the last 30 years with hit and miss efforts to get a draft bargain. What is the point of paying a QB this much money?
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 08:54 am
As fans we get wrapped up in the tactical decisions of the coaches and players, but with the advent of the salary cap, organizational strategy has become equally important. There will never be a Lombardi era Packer team again with all-pros scattered throughout the line-up. The salary cap insures that can't happen. As a result, the organization must have a cohesive strategy on how to fill out a roster to maximize success. Kansas City does a superb job of winning with offense and insures that free agency and the draft supports this philosophy.
Unfortunately the Packers have a front office that apparently doesn't have or discuss a cohesive strategy. You correctly point out that both TT and Gute have not used free agency or the draft to support Favre or Rodgers with weapons, very unlike KC which recognizes Mahommes is a HOF talent and they build around him.
Gute was clearly drafting for the post Rodgers era and that isn't unreasonable given Rodgers' age, but then Murphy resigns Rodgers. What is the overarching strategy here? The Packers could have traded Rodgers to Denver for a fortune in players and picks which would have been consistent with Gute's direction. Why did Murphy move in the opposite direction by resigning Rodgers? Was that in the best interests of the team or of Murphy who is near retirement and perhaps protecting his legacy with the Packers?
The only thing clear is that the front office is pulling in different directions and destroying the team in the process.
The_Baloney_Stops_Here
October 26, 2022 at 09:07 am
Inject this entire comment straight into my veins.
Since'61
October 26, 2022 at 12:41 pm
Guam I've answered your question about why Murphy is moving in the opposite direction of his GM on numerous threads here at CHTV. He is trying to keep the Packers relevant until he decides to retire. He has been the Packers President/CEO since 2007. Under his tenure the Packers have made the playoffs 12 out of 15 seasons.
The Packers missed the playoffs in 2008, Rodgers first year as a starter, then in 2017 when Rodgers was lost for the season in the 6th game of the season against the Vikings. The Packers were 4-1 at that point in the season.
Then again in 2018, the team had numerous injuries, Rodgers played through 2 injuries and McCarthy was going through the motions.
From Murphy's perspective Rodgers is his meal ticket and has kept the Packers relevant in the league for his entire time as team President. Murphy will retire in either 2024 or 25 at the latest. He has signed Rodgers through 2024 with cap hits that will kill the Packer's salary cap even if Rodgers retires. Murphy, Gute and MLF may realize that Love is not their guy based on what they have seen in practice. That means trading Rodgers, which they should have done after the 2021 seasons, would cause the Packers to quickly drop out of relevance in the league as they fall out of playoff contention. Also remember that MLF lobbied hard for Rodgers to be extended because he knew Rodgers gives the Packers the best chance to win and for him to keep his HC position.
So Murphy wants Rodgers for his legacy, MLF wants Rodgers so he can keep his job and Gute and Ball go along because ultimately Rodgers gives them the best chance to keep their jobs until Murphy retires and then maybe Gute moves up into Murphy's job and Ball moves into Gute's job. If everything breaks correctly the team wins another SB and everybody looks like a genius as they move on and/or moves up.
Rodgers is job security for the Packers management. It's that's simple. It's clear that Nono of them expected the wheels to fall off as they quickly as they have this season. But a combination of injuries, bad decisions and poor coaching have derailed this team and they don't seem to have a clue as to how to get back on track.
Rodgers is the easy target, but critical thinking and a review of management decisions points to this season becoming a cluster fxxk before the season even began. A weak OL, and a Practice Squad level receiving corps was the first clue. The second clue is a defense blowing coverages and taking bad penalties and the biggest clue is that the Packers STs have been the teams best unit even with a blocked FG and punt in the same game!!!
The upcoming Buffalo game will really be a view into the rest of our season. Either the Packers will be uncompetitive and lose badly or they will rise to the occasion and keep the game or maybe even pull out an upset victory. If they can't or won't step up on national TV we'll know where this season is going. Thanks, Since '61
Leatherhead
October 26, 2022 at 01:05 pm
It seems like there's a lot of conjecture on the assumption that "Rodgers is job security " and that's what is driving the decisions at 1265.
Murphy will retire at some point. Rodgers will retire at some point. Gutekunst and LaFleur will put a competitive product on the field without Rodgers or they'll be gone.
I don't think it was 'insane' to bring back the MVP. I think Rodgers has earned the right to "die with his boots on", as we would say in Texas. He's been a damn fine QB for us for quite a while and is still probably a little better than the guy behind him. There are only two paths.
1) Rodgers will rally his team and we'll start to look like we should. Or,
2) Rodgers will not rally his team, and we'll continue along on a very disappointing season.
The future cap hits on Rodgers are based on different assumptions whether he retires, or it's a trade, or whatever, but I think the Packer brass has a different idea of what the future cap is going to look like. It's entirely possible that it could be a minimal hit if he retires, and even that can be negotiated.
GBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGBGGB
"Packers STs have been the teams best unit even with a blocked FG and punt in the same game!!!"
And yet we're 3-4, versus 6-1 like we were with the horrible, no good, rotten STs of last year. Couldn't resist.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 03:35 pm
Nobody has a right to give 50 million (more) to let a guy “die with his boots on” unless it’s his personal money. If that is what Murphy did, he should be run out of town.
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 01:49 pm
If your logic is correct Since '61, then why was Murphy's subordinate (Gute) drafting for the last three years like the plan was to cut ties with Rodgers at the end of his contract in 2021? If Rodger is the meal ticket, Gute should have been drafting quite differently over the past three years (WRs, TEs and not drafting a replacement QB).
I rather suspect there was an agreed plan in place that Rodgers was to be traded/let go at the end of his 2021 contract (which contradicts the "meal ticket" theory). Murphy apparently scrapped this plan and reversed course to resign Rodgers last winter. At that point I buy your argument about Murphy and his legacy, but I doubt the rest of senior management bought into that for the simple reason they are going to be left with an incredible salary cap mess when Murphy and Rodgers retire. A mess that could get all of them fired.
I believe this is all on Murphy and his legacy and that he screwed up a viable plan for the Packers future which would have included trading Rodgers for players and draft capital last winter. There are no guarantees in that future, but it looks much brighter than an aging QB with a short horizon and an horrendous salary cap for several years.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 03:38 pm
Murphy is Gute’s boss. Change instructions or fire him if he’s not following the plan. Murphy can’t say he wasn’t paying attention because he’s talked up many of the moves and certainly was in the lead in the need to bring Rodgers back the last 2 years.
jannesbjornson
October 26, 2022 at 08:05 pm
They blew the Love pick, Rodgers turned in MVP performances and they didn't stock the shelf with all-star replacements. It is a management Fail. "61 is correct regarding the defense of the Brand. Rodgers is their main draw from a marketing perspective. I would surely hope Gutedkunst or Low-Ball are Never considered for the president's position. They made a mistake bringing in Murphy. Andrew Brandt should have run this ship. He would follow the Harlan legacy.
Since'61
October 26, 2022 at 11:30 pm
Absolutely correct about Brandt. As for the Love pick I agree they blew it. But it's done and here we are.
Thanks< Since '61
Since'61
October 27, 2022 at 08:21 am
Guam yes Gute has been drafting like the Packers were moving on from Rodgers but let's remember that most 1st round WRs were gone by the time the Packers were on the clock. I think that if Jefferson was still on the board in 2020 they would have taken him before Love. They could have picked Love in the second round.
We'll never know who was left on the board when the Packers slot came up during each round in '20 or '21. Gute tried to make the best picks to strengthen the team.
Regardless of what the plan was or is once Murphy made the statement "We're not idiots", in response to a question about extending Rodgers the die was pretty much cast. The only remaining question at that point was how much cap space will be taken up.
I've worked with hundreds of CEOs and Corporate Presidents during my career and many of them are notorious for changing their minds or their plans in a heartbeat or more likely based on their last quarter's earnings or current stock price. And while the Packers are a non-profit organization a significant part of Murphy's job is to protect the brand and for better or worse the brand has become and still is Rodgers. Yes, there is probably a post-Rodgers transition plan, at least conceptually, at 1265. But the reality is that for now Rodgers remains the straw that stirs the drink. Thanks, Since '61
Guam
October 27, 2022 at 04:17 pm
I certainly agree with your last two paragraphs Since '61, but am much less certain about the first two paragraphs. Your take is that Gute drafted what he could given his position in the draft. However we have seen multiple examples of Gute moving up in the draft (Savage, Amari Rodgers, Christian Watson) and if he really wanted Jefferson he could have moved up to get him. He didn't and preferred to select a QB. I think that was part of the post Rodgers era plan that senior management developed and agreed with until Murphy changed course.
And for what it is worth (likely not much) I was the CEO of a communications company. And protecting your brand is important. Both short term and long term. Murphy picked the short term brand over the long term brand. And I suspect for the purpose of preserving his legacy rather than for the good of the organization.
Packerpasty
October 26, 2022 at 02:04 pm
What you said here speaks the truth...""Rodgers is the easy target, but critical thinking and a review of management decisions points to this season becoming a cluster fxxk before the season even began. A weak OL, and a Practice Squad level receiving corps was the first clue. The second clue is a defense blowing coverages and taking bad penalties and the biggest clue is that the Packers STs have been the teams best unit even with a blocked FG and punt in the same game!!!"" the warning signs were there, did anyone actually think Lazard is WR #1??? And Bak had a very serious injury, no one should have counted on him being 100% perhaps never...Rodgers will retire, Love will be very mediocre and the "gory years" will return...oh well, theres the sledding hill, and beer, brats and bleachers, can't take that away..
Leatherhead
October 26, 2022 at 01:25 pm
Hey Guam. I can maybe take a stab at this question:
"Murphy resigns Rodgers. What is the overarching strategy here?"
If all the Packer brass, and the coaches, sat down in a room and were asked whether the Packers would be better in 2022 with Rodgers or Love, it would have been Rodgers. There were cap issues, but if the operating assumption is that the cap is going up, you could make it happen. And they did.
So we put the returning MVP on the field and gave Love another season to learn, grow, and develop. I don't think that's a bad organizational decision, on the face of it.
I think the Murphy/Gutekunst strategy has always been to ride Rodgers as long as they could AND to prepare for the day when they couldn't. It's working!! They got two MVP seasons out of him!! He's still as good as half the starting QBs in the league, we're still in the hunt for the playoffs.
We could have traded Rodgers. We probably wouldn't have been much worse, record-wise. I thought we should do it. But we didn't, and I don't think that was a terrible decision to bring back the MVP. Let's play out the season and see what happens. We can play better than we have.
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 02:15 pm
"If all the Packer brass, and the coaches sat down in a room and were asked whether the Packers would be better in 2022 with Rodgers or Love, it would have been Rodgers."
Right answer to the question Leatherhead, but the wrong question asked. If the Packer brass is only planning for next year, they all should be fired. The proper question should have been "Will the Packers be better in 2022 though 2025 with Rodgers or with Love and additional players and draft choices?". (The 2025 date is flexible as the long term can be defined differently by different organizations, but it damn sure isn't just 2022.)
It is hard to answer "Rodgers" to any question that involves a future. The rebuild has to begin sometime and the Packers had a golden opportunity to load up on young players and draft choices to jump start the future. They blew it.
I suspect Packers will play better this year, but the future (2023 and beyond) is not bright with an aging and declining QB and a bad salary cap situation.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 03:30 pm
This disconnect is impossible to deny. It’s clearly evident. The big question is why?
Murphy changed course possibly several times, but at least once in February. He the only one with the power to both approve the GMs course and me then to fly in its face without firing him for pursuing it.
barutanseijin
October 26, 2022 at 07:27 pm
Agreed. The failures in the front office are what people miss when they obsess about the coaches.
The QB is what he is. Murphy chose to have him back at the expense of other positions and this is the result. Maybe a Belichick or Reed could squeeze better performance out of this team, but it still lacks talent in key spots.
Packers2020
October 26, 2022 at 08:42 am
Guam,
I agree.
I think until Murphy is gone this team will not go anywhere. He has made some really stupid decisions and I think he is pulling the strings with Gute to a certain degree.
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 08:57 am
Gute reports to Murphy. Why these two are not on the same page is beyond me.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 12:32 pm
One suggestion would be that a GM has a plan two or three years in the making. I presume that was agreed. However, Murphy has changed direction and gone contrary too it. That’s usually how contradictions in this scale arise. It’s also a common way how senior leaders undermine organizations by imposing a direction at odds with things already irredeemably set in motion.
LLCHESTY
October 26, 2022 at 05:18 pm
I'd say since 2020 Gutey is drafting 2 or 3 years behind. They needed DL and WR help that year and he did that this year. 2021 still needed DL and WR help but CB was an issue. CBs don't need to be drafted in the 1st round though.
Obviously the way to stop playing catch-up is a complete rebuild where you know there's going to be short term pain(lots of losses) but, if you chose wisely, long term gain.
jannesbjornson
October 26, 2022 at 08:44 pm
I was on a fence regarding Stokes over his teammate, Tyson Campbell. Could have moved down a bit and bagged another pick. Stokes should be watching film of Al Harris. Let him press and Savage has to be watching the deep balls.
kagood
October 26, 2022 at 09:01 am
Exactly!
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 12:28 pm
There is critical point in your comment. If the leadership didn’t approve of what Gute was doing for the last three years then there was plenty of time to change course. During that time both Murphy and Rodgers spoke of the last dance type notion. The roster continues in that basis inexorably. Then in winter this year we made a totally contradictory call in spite of it coming with no cap to try change course. Then we sailed through the summer as if there was no issue.
The outcome is not, or shouldn’t be, surprising. Yet it is to many. These contradictions were obvious, in plain view. Many here and elsewhere saw them. Yet not in Lambeau,
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 02:01 pm
Thanks CW. I made essentially the same point responding to Since'61 above. There had to be an agreement among senior management that supported Gute's drafting over the last three years (i.e moving on from Rodgers after his 2021 contract) or Gute was being significantly insubordinate to Murphy for quite some time. Murphy then reversed course on the plan last winter with predictable and adverse consequences to the organization.
There were no guarantees that a boat load of players and picks would have made the Packers continue their relevancy in the league (so much depends on Love or his replacement), but the Packers are just about guaranteed irrelevancy with a declining, aging QB and a massive salary cap problem for several years.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 07:51 pm
Yes, I agree. I agree with ‘61 as to what Murphy thought. My point all along is that while some errors are understandable, this error was very much not. What has happened was probable in February, only the degree of LaFleur’s deficiency has proved greater than suspected. If 61 is right, Murphy’s grasp of reality is extremely worrying.
Guam
October 27, 2022 at 08:20 am
One way or another, Murphy's remaining tenure in Green Bay is short. Unfortunately his legacy is going to handicap this team for years after his departure. And had he followed the original plan, he could have made a bold statement about the future of the Packers. The best laid plans of mice and men........
jannesbjornson
October 27, 2022 at 08:59 pm
They have no obligation to let this guy ride out on his own terms.
tobinrote
October 26, 2022 at 08:11 am
mild mannered tony dungy called out rodgers during half time sunday night: he showed the throw at daubs feet and then noted a wide open guy in blown coverage on the right. same an another poorly thrown short throw. Problem is we are stuck with AR's contract chewing up the salary cap no matter what we do. no team would be stupid enough to take him and assue the contract funny how age finally catches up to you and his abilities have gone south on a bullet train
Packerpasty
October 26, 2022 at 02:06 pm
If your paying attention, Dungy been calling out Rodgers for years now..and on every play in every game played on Sunday, someone can be shown to be open down the field...QB's can't see it all in the time they have to make a decision, especially with the Packers crappy O line..
LLCHESTY
October 26, 2022 at 05:21 pm
Did Dungy point out that Doubs and Watson ran into each other right before that throw to Doubs' feet? Because of that Doubs certainly wasn't where he was supposed to be and Watkins was open because the Commander DBs we're wondering WTF was that? But yeah that was on Rodgers.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 07:59 pm
Now you are just losing the plot. I assume you mean Watkins. And I think a little less of Frankie’s old vintage.
LLCHESTY
October 27, 2022 at 09:58 pm
Yes I did. And the point is neither of them were where they should've been, as Watkins said he drove inside instead of outside because of the press from the CB which put him directly in Doubs' path.
Handsback
October 26, 2022 at 08:14 am
I think we are watching the clash of the titans in real time. MLF has a way to win (I know an assumption on my part, but he has a good track record.) and AR can't/won't abide by it.
It's a Mexican Standoff and the team sufferers until its over.
I'll say one more thing...adding another wideout is fool's gold....shinny and bright but crumbles in you hand. The canidates out there are either too old, too young, too expensive , or have too much LOFT...lack of freaking talent.
Besides it wouldn't matter anyway AR would hit them in their ankles and blast them for running the wrong route.
Defensively....this team has an attitude issue. They seem to lack a killer instinct.
Alway next year.
Razer
October 26, 2022 at 08:29 am
...adding another wideout is fool's gold...
True dat. Rodgers and his trust issues don't make for easy new additions. By the time our QB develops enough chemistry with a new WR the leaves will be turning again.
Razer
October 26, 2022 at 08:23 am
After watching what the Packers are putting on the field, I do have a truly polluted mindset. The feeling that many of us are expressing doesn't bode well for this team\this year. If you don't believe that your coach is smart enough nor tough enough to right the ship then - goodbye ship. LaFleur does look like he is in over his head and he looks like he has little control over what his QB is doing. Big problem when your leader isn't a leader.
The other thing that not many are talking about is the return of Tom Clements. He was a surly prick on his first stint on the Packers staff and Rodgers reflected that attitude. Clement's return has our QB going back to his old ways and he is being enabled to think that his performance was acceptable on Sunday. Never liked him under McCarthy and I doubt that he is helping LaFleur much today.
Sorry but David Bakhtiari is done. I love the guy and his grit but 2 years and multiple surgeries do not bode well for our LT. The position is just too demanding and less than 100 percent recovery isn't going to be good enough. Get out while your knee is still functional.
BruceC1960
October 26, 2022 at 08:28 am
I too wonder who AR is referring to that might need to sit out ? Maybe it is Doubs and Stokes. But wouldn’t Jenkins, Yosh, Newman, Amari, Gary, Savage and Lazard qualify too? Is our 53 man roster big enough. Oddly AR doesn’t see himself on that list. Blames everyone but himself. Maybe he has a future in politics when he is done.
PeteK
October 26, 2022 at 11:13 am
Sit Gary and Lazard ? They have made a few mistakes, but they are two of the few players that are playing to their potential.
BruceC1960
October 26, 2022 at 11:24 am
I’m not saying to sit them, when AR says to sit guys that keep making the same mistakes, these guys fit that description. Lazards drops and Gary not holding the edge against the run. I wouldn’t sit either one of them. That’s the point. AR message was not thought out very well.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 12:42 pm
Who really has played below expectations and has made serial errors? A rookie shouldn’t have many expectations and can be expected to make errors. Among the vets? I’d say Rodgers is as up there as any of the vets. Maybe more if you blame him for some baffling RPO calls.
If it’s not vets then it starts becoming a cover for vets only and then less talent than before or it’s simply subjective, which destroys a team. If this is a call to just field Cobb, Watkins, Lazard, Tonyan then maybe it is time to calm it a day. We aren’t going anywhere good with that alone.
ricky
October 26, 2022 at 08:34 am
First, do you think LaFleur should be on the hot seat? Not whether he is or isn't, but your personal opinion. Second, this is Rodgers' team, for better or worse. And he has apparently decided he wants a new coach. A lot of the stuff he is doing is the same things that got McCarthy fired, with his poor play, questionable decision-making, and yelling at the sidelines. McCarthy did bring Favre under control early on in his tenure in Green Bay, but this situation is totally different. As I've written repeatedly, once the Packers signed Rodgers to his new contract, it became his team, because the cap hit they'd take for him retiring at this point would be disastrous. This is on the team; after all, why should a player turn down an incredible deal that pays them a lot, and also gives them a lot of leverage?
The_Baloney_Stops_Here
October 26, 2022 at 10:58 am
Bingo. Just like some anonymous gm said the other day, the Packers created a monster. Its exactky i sent Mark Murphy a very angry email immediately after the news of Rodgers' extension broke. They crowned him king and now he has all the keys to the castle. And he knows it too.
pacman
October 26, 2022 at 08:38 am
I've been quiet for the last couple weeks watching all the blame getting thrown around so nothing to add. It's a very sad state of affairs.
I'm going back to my mantra - it's MLF. He's the one that hasn't made changes quickly enough during games (or at all), he's the one that put the new coaches that are failing in their positions, he's the one that is ultimately responsible for getting players ready, he's the one that keeps talking about getting AJ more touches and doesn't, etc. The last one IS worthy of getting him fired NOW as that is directly under his immediatel control and he simply doesn't do it. Or if AR is changing the call, then it is indeed time to sit AR.
If we had an owner, something would have changed by now. It is ridiculous to think that professional coaches have to read this site to know what to do.
There might be personal dynamics that we don't know about, but AR has digressed in accuracy as he did a few years back when they drafted Love. I suspect that management give the coaches another few games to see if they can possibly revive the season. Very doubtful that is doable without AR returning to form and have someone to throw to. Else, they will tell MLF to play Love (at least half the game) and the team goes through a major rebuild. We have to pay AR anyways so might as well see if anyone wants to pay something for him and see if Love is any good before we cut/pay him.
It's been a good run with Favre/Rodgers. My Viking/Bear fan family has little sympathy for us.
croatpackfan
October 26, 2022 at 10:01 am
"My Viking/Bear fan family has little sympathy for us."
Why should they?
BruceC1960
October 26, 2022 at 11:31 am
Management will never tell MLF to play Love. It’s a no win situation for them. If Loves plays well, they will look like fools for extending Rodgers. If Love plays poorly, they will look like fools for ever drafting him.
Rebecca
October 26, 2022 at 08:50 am
Trust the plan. ‘“ While I went for the easy pun, "who's in command" is really the main question I have about these Green By Packers - and specifically the offense. It's hard for me to understand the scheme they are running based on the personnel they have. Good coaches find the style that best suits the abilities of the players. Of course, LaFleur's hands are a bit tied, although it's his own fault for being so deferential to Aaron Rodgers right from the get-go. It's likely too late at this point to try to wrest full control of his team, so the success of this team is likely in serious jeopardy."
I mean I just think the players need to make the plays that are called. Regardless of who is calling them. If they would stop dropping catchable passes, stop lining up wrong and just having negative plays, maybe they could actually do something on offense.
- In my prediction for this game, I stated that a loss to Washington would be on a par with the loss to Arizona that got McCarthy fired. Of course, no one is getting fired here, but that doesn't mean you couldn't build a case for it.
- "Not Stoked for Doubs - It was a really rough day for Eric Stokes and Romeo Doubs. I have a feeling they're the two main guys Rodgers was referring to when he said players that are making too many mistakes shouldn't be playing so much. Although I do wonder if that applies to himself, also?"
I am wondering who he is talking about. Clearly there are a few players that he thinks shouldn't be getting as much playing time as others. Could AJ Dillon be one? He has not been catching a lot of passes of late. He had another bad drop in this game. One that would have gained a lot of yards.
As far as Rodgers himself, he hasn't been perfect. But anyone that wants to blame Rodgers for the Washington game, needs to rewatch it. 7/8 dropped passes. A ton of penalties. A defense that dropped 4 interceptions. Their punt returner that changed the momentum of the game.
- "More than the losses to the Giants and Jets, this game truly was a comedy of errors and "almosts." The defense could have easily had 4-5 interceptions in the first half, all of which would have given the ball to the Packers in Washington territory."
The defense while played really well in the first half, struggles with making game changing plays that could put teams away. Then they can't get the stops when they need to. Its time we stop saying 'well he is a db for a reason'. No enough of that excuse. catch the damn ball. Make a play!
- "Ron Rivera with some words the Packers should pay attention to. "We ran the ball effectively," Rivera said. "When you can do that, you can chew the clock and you can possess the ball. It seems to be a pretty good formula." Um, we wouldn't know..."
I will say that Jones can bust one at any point. But they have not ran the ball well at all. Perhaps with the new OL and after a week of playing together they will start to gel. They do need to get more attempts. But they have to stop holding, and stop getting into negative situations.
- "DBak - Gotta feel for the guy. My total guess is that he's still needing to get the knee drained regularly. Hard to criticize him, but plenty of asshole Packers fans still do."
This will probably be the way it will be the rest of the year. I will say though I liked the way Tom played. He has a lot to learn, but I thought he played well.
- "Give Joe Barry some credit - he's reading CheeseheadTV and trying some of the things we keep asking for here."
As in blitzing Quay off the edge? Yup. about time he listened.
- "Sure seems that AJ Dillon is being marginalized more every game. I get that he hasn't lit the world on fire, but you would think on fourth and one they would make use of him. But no, let's throw a WR bubble screen."
Dillon has marginalized himself. He has not played well this year so far. He is looking slow. He is not breaking tackles or making anyone miss. He has been dropping passes. I like Dillon but he has not been very good. His rookie year he averaged 5.3 yards per carry. Last year he averaged 4.3. Currently he has averaged 3.9. For receptions last year he averaged 9.2 yards per catch. THis year 6.2. He simply hasn't been as dynamic. I am a big fan of Dillon. He just hasn't been that good. Perhaps some of it is from the OL. Maybe this new OL will allow the RB's to have greater success.
However I think it’s time to start using another RB some. Clearly they have no trust in Taylor. He has yet to have a carry or anything on offense. Either get Hill on the roster or bring up Goodson. Goodson I think would be a great option for the offense in terms of the passing game. They could use him in the Ervin type of role. Motion, and in the passing game. He could be a very good piece to add.‘ I agree. Excellent post.
Razer
October 26, 2022 at 09:15 am
...Dillon has marginalized himself. He has not played well this year so far. He is looking slow. He is not breaking tackles or making anyone miss....
Totally agree. A big power back with speed and hands and he falls over with the first hint of contact. I don't know but I am going to call out some coaching on this front. He is running too high and he is dancing around behind the LOS. Get low and use your quads as Lombardi intended.
BuckyBadger
October 26, 2022 at 10:00 am
Won't matter who is running the ball, the OL can't hold the point of attack. Dillon had some good carriers when they blocked for him but they never have fed him consistently due to the OL missing assignments.
Tundraboy
October 26, 2022 at 10:26 pm
Nah they never consider using any of the players who showed some talent or versatility.
We draft but don't really develop in any normal time frame. It takes years and when it fails we end up holding onto picks longer than we ever should (Amari) How can any of this and last year's rookies develop when they only play with Love or other rookie QBs in the preseason and when the starting QB doesn't even bother putting in time with them in camp yet demands perfection. No wonder it takes the team three to four games to get up to speed year after year. And this year? Looks like it's going to take a half dozen or more if at all.
13TimeChamps
October 26, 2022 at 09:15 am
Ok, conspiracy time:
7/8 dropped passes and 4 dropped INTs? All in one game? What are the odds? Almost like they're not really trying. Maybe...just maybe...a message is being sent to a certain QB who they are sick of trashing them on TV shows and press conferences?
Makes about as much sense as anything else going on out there.
Guam
October 26, 2022 at 09:47 am
You may have something 13TC. Clearly Adams didn't want to play with the Packers anymore. Was it Rodgers he was tired of?
BuckyBadger
October 26, 2022 at 09:58 am
You are saying that these young players are spearheading their own careers to spite a guy who has made his money in the league? That would be the dumbest move by any person in that franchise all season and there have been some dandies.
croatpackfan
October 26, 2022 at 10:20 am
I understand your logic, and to some extend it hold the ground. But, we do not know what is going on behind closed doors, in locker room. If things went far south that is possibility. That can be form of strike.
Also, ACR pass through very similar difficulties when he was drafted. He needed 2 to 3 season to putnhimself together. Now he is doing the same to young players, rookies and 1 year "old" in the NFL.
Publicly saying that everybody is guilty except him through very carefuly choice of words will not help rookies nor a year young players. Problems with Doubs started when he didn't hold the ball on that TD pass. From that moment he lost the confidence and things went south.
Also, maybe there are not young players who started that. That might started from some older players (exclude Cobb and Old Dog).
However, we do not know what the hell is happening there. If we go further, it might be that ACR working on Gutekunst, not on MLF. There may be so many reasons why Packers are in disjoint.
Who ever is guilty, the product is horrifying bad.
13TimeChamps
October 26, 2022 at 11:21 am
Football is the ultimate team sport. How long before members of that team get sick and tired of another member publicly and repeatedly trashing them? Especially when the member doing the trashing is the same member who was doing mind expanding drugs down in South America while the rest of the members were busting their collective asses during OTA's.
I offered nothing more than a conspiracy theory. Do I believe that is what is actually happening? No. Would I be shocked to find out it was? Also no.
As another on here posted...Rodgers isn't exactly the kind of teammate you'd run through a brick wall for.
The_Baloney_Stops_Here
October 26, 2022 at 10:07 am
I said the same thing ago 2 weeks ago when people complained about the blocking. My exact words were "I wouldn't want to block for his punkass either." I played right tackle in high school and had to block for a complete dbag quarterback. Now I never blew a block on purpose, but I never once helped him off the ground either. Everyone hated this guy. Cant imagine Rodgers is well liked by many on this team anymore. The qb has to be a guy his teammates will run through a brick wall for. Rodgers aint it. Not even remotely close.
Tundraboy
October 26, 2022 at 10:39 pm
I wouldn't doubt it either. I think they start out with a good intent but you drop a pass and your looking over your shoulder and questioning yourself, which usually leads to more mistakes.
The_Baloney_Stops_Here
October 26, 2022 at 09:58 am
I dont generally call for people to be fired, but MLF might want to consider giving Clements the pink slip. Never liked the hire in the first place and Rodgers seems to regressing in almost every category and I'm not talking about numbers either. His mechanics, which already havent been great for a long time, have gotten worse, his decision making is worse, his accuracy is worse (which could be a direct result of the previous 2 points), and just his overall presence as a player has declined. If the brain trust is too chicken s*** to hold Rodgers accountable for his failures and degenerate behavior, then maybe they can get the point accross by firing his buddy/steward/emotional support animal cuz the guy doesnt seem to be bringing much to this team. And its clear theyre never going to play Love before he hits free agency so Love is no excuse to keep him either.
MainePackFan
October 26, 2022 at 10:18 am
Aaron Rodgers SUCKS....SUCks...SUcks...Sucks...sucks....Echo Chamber much?? :))
stockholder
October 26, 2022 at 10:48 am
Did you read the pigs in s***. Comment?
MainePackFan
October 26, 2022 at 06:11 pm
No, I didn't see it.
HarryHodag
October 26, 2022 at 10:45 am
I know one thing for sure: it's easy to pile on when things are going bad. I was one of the 'pilers on' during the 70's and 80's. I'm not going to do that now. An upset win over the Bills would change the mindset here and elsewhere.
I fully agree with Al that the most disturbing thing for me is the 'vibe' of this team. I'm not sure Matt LF has lost the team, but it appears to me Aaron Rodgers runs the show and the results have not been good. Rodgers has his core of friends, all of them handsomely paid, and outside of that realm are a bunch of guys going 'what's up?' I will never change the idea that Rodgers tanked to get Mike McCarthy fired and Matt LF knows it. MLF also knows there is literally nothing he can do about Rodgers. The contract AR signed is good PR, but as the weeks unfold it is clearer to me that his contract is an extreme albatross that will take years to remedy. Rodgers should have been moved to Denver last year.
This brings me to Ted Thompson. Yours truly blistered Ted aplenty during the years. He made some truly dumb draft selections and other personnel moves. He also made some great ones. He had the courage to do the right thing long term for the organization. One was drafting Aaron Rodgers when he had Brett Favre, and the second was to jettison Favre when Rodgers was ready to go. The current management 'arrangement' has left the Packers with an enormous contract load and little flexibility to make the team better. It also has left them with an aging QB who seems to think he's untouchable, a real problem. It has left the head coach put to the side trying to make silk purse out of a sow's ear.
I hope this isn't the beginning of 20 years of frustration.
The_Baloney_Stops_Here
October 26, 2022 at 11:06 am
Imo, whats even more important than winning this game, is establishing some kind of an identity. This team needs something, literally anything, to hang its hat on or one big win will likely just be an outlier. Every good team has an identity. This team needs to find their's quickly.
T7Steve
October 26, 2022 at 11:20 am
Let's go for the best special teams in the NFL! Have to have something, right?
Dragon5
October 26, 2022 at 11:23 am
Most here would argue that we're particularly devoid of talent on the offensive side of the ball, so I pose this question to everyone...
If mgmt / coaching couldn't finish the job WITH talent during thrice 13-3 seasons,,,what makes you think they will WITHOUT it?
PeteK
October 26, 2022 at 11:46 am
---Last season we had good success rushing the ball. This season with 2 all pro O linemen back and 2 rookie linemen with more seasoning; the rushing attack should have been dominating. This could have put less pressure on an offense minus Adams. Even a combo of Payton/Staubach couldn't overcome this terrible blocking.
---I have been a critical of AR of late, but less this season. Even though I wish he would keep quiet, even Mahomes and Allen misfire a couple of times per game. AR is still making some great throws.
--- To see a great lineman like Bak injured and not playing is sad, but if he can't play anymore retire and go enjoy life.
Dragon5
October 26, 2022 at 12:32 pm
Past performance is not indicative of future results Pete; expect the unexpected.
Coldworld
October 26, 2022 at 11:49 am
LaFleur is clearly not in command. I see a lot think Gute is, but he almost certainly did not lead the charge to bring back Rodgers, that was Murphy. Nor was the contract negotiated his call. Ball does not answer to him but Murphy. Nor does Gute manage LaFleur and he certainly did not hire him.
Murphy deliberately set up a divide and rule system and hired a Head Coach who is clearly no leader who seems to hire non leaders beneath him. The result is the chaotic and contradictory mess we now see exposed by the departure of Talent driven by the retention of Rodgers removing the cover that talent had given to some extent to mask the reasons for repeated failures with much more balanced rosters.
The answer is no one and Murphy. The leader oversees a chaotic mess. LaFleur is him at a lower level. Recruitment in one’s own image.
packerbackerjim
October 26, 2022 at 01:06 pm
An Organizational Psychologist would have his or her hands full trying to get this motley crew on the same page.
Swisch
October 26, 2022 at 01:59 pm
The plausible and pathetic scenario of intentional disorganization that you describe, Coldworld, is more than troubling -- for of it can come no good for the Packers, and we become the ongoing quagmire of such franchises as the Commanders and Browns.
If Gute and LaFleur are indeed largely innocent of this divide-and-rule system, they may want to speak up to defend themselves from the debacle.
After three straight seasons of 13 wins, and even a couple of playoff wins along the way, it would seem Gute and LaFleur are eminently hirable by other teams if Murphy is indeed the bad guy and lets go of them.
The mistake Gute and LaFleur would have to own up to is going along with Murphy and his enabling of Aaron Rodgers as a prima donna disturbing and disrupting the balance of the team.
In doing so, Gute and LaFleur would be doing a service to all of us who root for and even love the Green Bay Packers, by exposing a rottenness at the very core of the organization in Murphy. Perhaps they could stay, and have an opportunity to do their jobs, to show their abilities, without undue interference from the top.
In any case, there might be enough public pressure to hasten the departure of Murphy, and so get the franchise back on solid ground.
***
I applaud you, Coldworld, for trying to get to the root of the problem with a thoughtful theory -- which I'm not qualified to opine upon due to lack of understanding.
Until we uncover the essence of the disorder, the place in which change must begin, the Packers will stumble around the NFL incoherently and indefinitely.
All the talk about such matters as play calling, the state of the offensive line, whether we should trade for a wide receiver, seems paltry if we don't fix any serious flaws and faults in management.
I've pegged Aaron Rodgers as the main problem for the Packers -- as a theory on my part that I think has lots of evidence behind it -- but if your theory about Murphy is correct, then he's the reason behind the difficulty with Rodgers, as well as the rest of "the chaotic and contradictory mess" that is now coming into view on Sundays.
***
All human things tend toward corruption unless there is a positive force for renewal and reform.
It seems up to the fans to get to the bottom of the ugliness on the field by looking for the ultimate causes, and holding accountable those responsible, perhaps even running them out of town.
croatpackfan
October 26, 2022 at 04:13 pm
Swisch,
if it quacks like a duck, if it flies like a duck, if it swims like a duck, then it's a duck! That is the logical explanation of mess that Packers are in. Murphy change the structure of the Packers football organization by destroying hierarchy and pu himself on the top. He is the guy every one of them are liable. So, not Brian Gutekunst, not Russ Ball nor MLF can bypass Murhy. He is the direct boss to every one of them. So, all decisions goes through Murphy. BG can not fire MLF or Ball and vice versa.
Unfortunatelly, that kind of organization work in business, but not in parts where the line of events are subsequent - it should start with BG who should be boss of MLF and MLF should be boss of his coordinators and responsible for aquired team (roster & PS). BG is responsible to "purchase" players through draft, free agency and trades. To be able to make high quality product they must agree on what kind of players should be drafted, traded or signed through free agency. Russ Ball is guy from side who should work close to BG taking care of the SC. Mike Murphy should get only reports on activities and status.
If you are the owner of company would you allow your "purchasing" manager to supply production with iron, when your production produce gold jewelry? If that happen you'll not produce gold jewelry, but trinket.
I suppose that happened to Packers. There was no communication between "purchasing department and production" and we have trinket!
Swisch
October 26, 2022 at 06:38 pm
It seems as though Murphy may be domineering and meddling in the affairs of the Packers, but perhaps not wanting to be seen as such.
Perhaps we need to call out Murphy for the ruinous decision to force Rodgers on the Packers; but, then again, we don't know if Gute and LaFleur were backing Murphy in keeping Rodgers, or protesting.
It seems a mess that threatens the Packers for years to come.
We need an honest accounting of Packers management to sort things out and set things aright.
pantz_bURp
October 26, 2022 at 03:29 pm
I guess that is Murphy's Law.
Leatherhead
October 26, 2022 at 11:53 am
"It was a really rough day for Eric Stokes and Romeo Doubs. I have a feeling they're the two main guys Rodgers was referring to when he said players that are making too many mistakes shouldn't be playing so much."
80% of our targets go to six guys: Doubs, Lazard, Tonyan, Jones, Watkins, Cobb. So I think there's a real good chance it's one of those. Probably not the veterans. Maybe it's the rookie who has had several drive-stopping drops. Doubs leads the team in targets, because he's the guy who hasn't missed time with injury, like Watkins and Lazard and Watson and Cobb have. I'd agree that maybe he's playing too much, but we have to line up the guys healthy enough to play.
T7Steve
October 26, 2022 at 12:30 pm
It's what you'd expect from a rookie and a second year DB in this league isn't it? That's how they learn. It's up to the vets to play well enough to overcome that stuff. That will rise up the young kids play and vice versa. Just like Campbell and Walker did in that game. I really believe Walker is opening some opportunities that are helping both play better. At first, he wasn't put in a position to do that, and it hurt Campbell too.
Leatherhead
October 26, 2022 at 01:32 pm
That's pretty much the way I see it. Inexperienced guys are more prone to making mistakes than the guys who've been around the track a few times.
Doubs is getting a lot of snaps and targets because he's healthy. Stokes is still better than the guy behind him. In a perfect world, you'd have time to develop guys and you wouldn't have to put them in a situation where they abused, but that's not the reality of the NFL.
LLCHESTY
October 26, 2022 at 05:25 pm
Maybe they should try Amari instead.
Packerpasty
October 26, 2022 at 02:15 pm
none of those six would be even a #2 WR or TE on the majority of NFL teams...mediocre bunch for sure..
Swisch
October 26, 2022 at 12:35 pm
It seems to be mainly up to Rodgers nowadays as to whether or not the Packers turn things around.
I'm still rooting for him to step up by standing down to the proper authority of his head coach and GM. He has enough responsibility on his hands as quarterback.
A change of attitude on the part of Rodgers to being more team-oriented and encouraging would lift up all the players and coaches and fans.
***
If Rodgers persists in arrogance, though, the only remedy may be to bench him game after game after game . . .
It would require the Packers GM and head coach to give a good reason, that Rodgers just isn't cooperative, that his ego is hurting the team.
The combination of sitting on the sidelines and getting a public reprimand may cause Rodgers to be humbled enough to change; or if not, to retire with some sort of settlement that lessens the crippling effect on the salary cap going forward.
Maybe it's better to warn Rodgers beforehand about the coming of this course of punishment, so that he has the possibility of changing beforehand and avoiding it.
The Packers management could be positive about working with Rodgers if he works with them, even as they are firm about putting him in his rightful place as a player, like any other player, who must yield to proper authority.
***
A whole season of Rodgers ruining the season by intrusiveness into coaching and personnel seems unbearable.
A switch to Love would at least be hope for the future, and some excitement in a young team striving with togetherness to succeed.
LLCHESTY
October 26, 2022 at 05:27 pm
"The combination of sitting on the sidelines and getting a public reprimand may cause Rodgers to be humbled enough to change; or if not, to retire with some sort of settlement that lessens the crippling effect on the salary cap going forward."
This is dumb. You think embarrassing a guy publicly is a good way of saying please don't take some of the money we owe you? 🤣🤣🤣
Swisch
October 26, 2022 at 06:25 pm
I have put forth embarrassing Rodgers as a last resort.
Whether he would want to be the guy, already fabulously rich, getting paid for doing nothing, and in the process crippling the Packers for years to come -- well, that's up to him.
I'd be glad for your better ideas, LLCHESTY.
jannesbjornson
October 26, 2022 at 10:26 pm
Shaming is a big thing in some of these religions...
pantz_bURp
October 26, 2022 at 01:45 pm
"Confessions of a Polluted Mindset" [Title]
I thought the article was about #12 confessing his thoughts.
Go Pack Go!
Swisch
October 26, 2022 at 02:21 pm
Well, it does seem #12 is the #1 in command of the Packers.
***
If Rodgers would relinquish some of his unwarranted command -- that is, his interference in coaching and personnel decisions -- then it seems he would have much more success for himself and his team.
I've been huge fan of Rodgers over the years until his arrogant usurpations of power -- and I'd much rather see him go out toward the top rather than near the bottom.
As it is, Rodgers would leave with what seems to be a highly tarnished legacy. How much better it would be if he cleaned up his act and threw himself into leading this team back from disarray into a determined drive for the playoffs.
***
With some humility, an agreeable and encouraging Rodgers could have a couple more seasons of success with the Packers and lead them to the fullness of their potential, with good feelings all around.
I think he still has plenty of talent. I still think the team has plenty of talent around him on offense and defense, even special teams.
It's up to Rodgers to decide if he wants to sulk and make excuses, or rather rally the troops to a spirited campaign for victory.
pantz_bURp
October 26, 2022 at 02:23 pm
Swisch, I appreciate your opinion and thoughts. You keep on keeping on, sir!✌️👍
LLCHESTY
October 27, 2022 at 02:57 am
Total BS. If Rodgers was in charge they wouldn't be running so many RPOs and the motion would be cut in half if not less.
This is simply what happens when you mate a poor outside skill position group with an offense that the rest of the NFL has figured out and a leader that reverts to his old,non working ways when the pressure mounts. LaFleur actually brought some new elements to the run game this year because defenses were figuring out the Shanahan inside zone runs. Those new ideas haven't been seen in weeks.
I guess Rodgers is to blame for all mental mistakes we're seeing every week too? Eliminate those and even with as bad as the offense has been they win two more games. I guess Rodgers should take charge like Starr did when Lombardi was coach hunh? We saw what a great leader Starr was when he was running the show.
Packerpasty
October 26, 2022 at 02:11 pm
spoiled crybaby Packer fans, get over it, the teams in rebuild..people want Love to play, that would be cruel and unusual punishment to stick him out there with this group of WR's...the only thing I wonder is what QB do the Packers have their eye on next years draft...or will they take another D lineman instead of a QB or WR...that seems to be the way they work..
Packerpasty
October 26, 2022 at 07:10 pm
well here's something I found that I agree with...
“ “The truth hurts and might not sound like good PR, but give Rodgers credit for seeing the facts and admitting them in an incredibly calm way. He has every right to be pissed as hell, but somehow the haters think he's not allowed real emotions amid a highly frustrating situation. Let's face the truth: Rodgers has more receivers drop passes than is close to acceptable. Guys run wrong routes constantly. And he's working with no name rookies and washed up receivers no one else really wanted (complete truth). The big truth about Green Bay is that the last ten plus years would have been pathetic without Rodgers. Don't bite the hand that feeds you, Cheeseheads. Rodgers has carried Green Bay on his back and now you're saying thanks by trashing him out when he tells the truth about sub-par,, unacceptable receivers? Watch the tape. The man has no consistent protection, a lousy run game (look at yardage), and worst of all, receivers so sub-par that any other quarterback would likely have 10+ interceptions by now (including Brady). “” but, once again the Rodgers haters won't see it that way...dont like it when he doesn't say anything, don't like it when he does..it will never change...
croatpackfan
November 01, 2022 at 08:20 am
It is always easy to call others who do not agree with your worship of one person to be haters. Sometimes those "haters" are people which have healthy logic and made truthful conclusions.
Sometimes it is just a mistake in judgement. Whatever it be, I doubt that here is much of ACR haters, they are more people with tendencies to question the top of the pack.